Grow your local business with Magic

Book a Magic demo, and explore tools that can help you operate, grow revenue and win today.

Tips & Business Growth

How to drive new business to your insurance agency

Explore effective strategies to drive new business to your insurance agency and boost your success in a competitive market.

Attracting and retaining customers has always been and will always be a constant challenge for insurance agencies, but the industry is changing rapidly. In today’s highly competitive market, it’s not enough to offer quality insurance products, they must constantly look for new ways to drive new business to your insurance agency. And agencies that don’t adapt will be left behind!

Good marketing and business development strategies, including understanding their target market, building an online presence, networking, offering promotions and discounts, and providing excellent customer service, can help insurance agencies create a solid foundation for growth and success.

In this article, we’ll explore some of the best ways to drive new business to an insurance agency that will help your company thrive in a challenging market.

Understand your target market

A successful insurance agency will know its target audience and understand their needs and preferences, which makes it easier to tailor marketing and business development strategies and attract new customers. This means if you want to drive new business to your insurance agency, you must identify your target market, and this boils down to three steps:


Who is your ideal customer? For example, if you specialise in home and car insurance, your target audience may be homeowners in a specific geographic area above a certain income level, but if you’re a business insurance specialist you could be looking for small to medium-sized businesses with a turnover of less than £1 million. There are so many factors to consider when defining your target audience, but some of the top factors include age, income/turnover, location, and occupation/industry.


Once you have identified your target audience, you need to discover their problems and needs so you can develop insurance products and services that meet them. This can involve conducting surveys or focus groups to gather information directly from potential customers, or researching industry trends and analysing competitors to see what they are doing well and where they can improve.


Market research is a key component to understanding your target market. By analysing industry data, conducting surveys, and monitoring customer feedback you can gain insights into their behaviour, preferences, and buying patterns. Armed with this information, you can then make informed decisions about marketing strategies, product offerings, and business development initiatives.

Build an online presence

A strong online presence is essential for driving new business to your insurance agency because it can help attract new customers, increase brand recognition, and improve customer engagement. Some of the key steps in building an online presence include:

Create a website

Very often, the first impression potential clients will have of your insurance agency is by visiting your website, so it’s important to make sure it’s professional, user-friendly, and up-to-date. Your website should include information about your insurance products and services, as well as your agency’s contact information, customer reviews, and testimonials.

Get social

Consistently posting relevant and engaging content on social media helps increase brand recognition and is a great way to build relationships with current and potential customers. Social media platforms can also be used to promote special offers and discounts, and to answer customer questions and concerns.

Optimise SEO

Using keywords in content and Meta tags can help improve your website’s visibility and increase the chances of potential customers finding your website when searching for insurance services. Another way to optimise your SEO is to create a Google Business Profile, which can help you reach a wider audience and attract new clients.

Business and community networking

Networking and community outreach programmes can help drive new business to your insurance agency. Building relationships with local businesses, participating in community events, and sponsoring local sports teams or events can help increase brand recognition and establish your agency as a trusted and respected community member.

Business networking

Collaborations with other local businesses mean you can offer joint promotions and cross-promote each other’s products and services, which help increase referrals and improve your visibility in the community.

Participating in community events

Entering teams in local charity events or participating in community fairs and festivals can help increase brand recognition and build relationships with potential clients. Being seen as an active member of your local community positions your insurance agency as a trusted and caring business, committed to your community’s well-being.

Local sponsorship

Sponsoring a local sports team or event gets your logo on kit or publicity materials, will expand your reach to a larger audience of potential customers, increasing your agency’s visibility and positioning you as a strong community advocate.

Promotions and discounts

Offering special packages for new customers, discounts for referrals, and loyalty rewards for long-term customers can help incentivise potential customers to choose your agency over the competition.

New customers

Creating special packages for new customers, such as discounted rates on specific insurance products, a bundle of services, or a free consultation with an insurance agent, can help entice them to choose your insurance agency over the competition. Offers can include:

Referral discounts

Providing a discount on products or services for referrals can incentivise existing customers to refer their friends and family to your insurance agency which helps spread the word about your agency and helps attract new business.

Loyalty rewards

Offering loyalty rewards for long-term customers on insurance products or services, a gift card, or other incentives shows your appreciation for their continued business and encourages them to remain loyal to your agency.

Get more customer reviews

Actively soliciting customer feedback helps you gain valuable insights into what customers think about every aspect of your insurance agency. With a better understanding of your clients’ needs and wants, you can use this information to improve your services and increase customer satisfaction. 

To show you value feedback and are committed to improving your services, it’s important to respond to every customer review, whether positive or negative. For positive reviews, a quick ‘thank you’ message will suffice. However, when it comes to negative reviews, it’s even more important to respond quickly, address the complaints and find ways to resolve the issues raised.

You can use all the insights you gain from reviews to make further improvements to your services, such as changing processes, updating policies, or even adding new services.

Reviews can help build trust and credibility, and help improve your local search engine rankings, which can help attract new business.

A tool like Magic can help you automatically generate review requests for popular review sites, including Google, Facebook, Yelp, TrustPilot, and more. Magic Reviews lets you consolidate and monitor all your reviews from one dashboard and respond using smart templates.

Key takeaway

Driving new business to an insurance agency requires a comprehensive and well-thought-out strategy. By taking a holistic approach which includes understanding your target market, building a strong online presence, participating in networking and community outreach, offering promotions and discounts, and encouraging customer reviews, insurance agencies can improve customer satisfaction and establish a strong and successful business.

About Magic

Magic helps local businesses grow. Thousands of local businesses use Magic to get more online reviews, win new customers, easily manage customer conversations and grow sales. Magic offers these features:

  • Reviews: Get more reviews with easy review requests for popular review sites like Google, Facebook, Yelp, TrustPilot, and more. Rank high on local search and enhance your visibility on Google. 
  • Inbox: Keep track of customer conversations across channels in one inbox, including SMS, Facebook, Instagram, and Gmail. Manage conversations better as a team and do more with industry specific templates. 
  • Text Marketing: Drive more sales with instant text campaigns and reach your customers at the right moment with automation. Use prebuilt templates to send out text campaigns in minutes. 
  • Webchat: Turn website visitors into customers with SMS powered Webchat. Chat to website visitors directly through SMS so you won’t miss a lead, even when they leave your website. 

Looking to grow your local business? Book in a demo call now. Follow us on Instagram and Facebook

Share this article

Grow your business with Magic today

Get more reviews, make more sales. Book a free demo to see how it works.

Get helpful tips to your inbox

Learn about local business market trends and insights.
Subscribe to our free newsletter.

Additional guides on Magic